A trial in Brazil sent me looking for old ways to grow grapes. I ended up reading about robots that carry them.
Minimal intervention comes up all the time in wine, usually when people talk about what happened in the cellar. When I read about the grape trial in Brazil, I saw a version of it I hadn’t given much thought to. The growers could change what they planted and potentially spend less of the season spraying it.
EPAMIG, the state agricultural research agency in Minas Gerais, tested eight disease-resistant wine grape varieties in the south of the state and made small batches of wine from them. The varieties are known as PIWIs, from the German for fungus-resistant vines. In the last summer cycle and the winter cycle, the researchers sprayed three times for powdery mildew and got through both cycles without a fungicide spray for downy mildew.
How had people kept grapes from rotting before they knew what caused it? Looking for an answer took me to a Roman farming manual from the first century.
What growers could do by hand
Columella advised growers to pull leaves from vines in cool, damp, shady places so the fruit could ripen without rotting. In hot, sunny places he wanted the bunches covered. If the vine didn’t have enough leaves of its own, he suggested bringing in some leaves or even straw. I like how much his advice depends on where you’re standing. The leaves you’d pull in one vineyard are the shade you’d bring in by hand in another.
Columella, De re rustica, Book V
Two diseases from North America gave European growers new problems in the 19th century. Powdery mildew appeared in the 1840s, and growers found they could control it with sulfur. Downy mildew, caused by a water mold, was documented in France in 1878. In the 1880s, growers in Bordeaux began using copper sulfate mixed with lime to control it. By the late 20th century, some synthetic fungicides could act inside plant tissue after infection had begun. Using products that work the same way over and over could favor the strains that survived them.
American Phytopathological Society on grape downy mildew · History of fungicides
U.S. organic growers can still use certain sulfur and copper products. Demeter sets additional limits on copper for biodynamic growers because it can build up in soil over time. When a grower talks about spraying less, those are two of the treatments they may be trying to cut back on.
U.S. organic crop production rules · Demeter USA farm standard
What someone means by organic
Over the years in wine retail, I’ve heard the same question from people looking at the organic section. Most of the bottles they see are ten or fifteen dollars. They want something a little fancier. A certified organic Napa Cabernet might be right there in the shop with the other Cabernets.
I’d ask if they cared about certification or if they’d consider a wine from a producer who could tell them how the grapes were grown. For some people the certification was the whole point. For others it opened up a lot more of the shop. I think of Frenchtown Farms in North Yuba, which describes tending and harvesting its vines by hand and spraying elemental sulfur at certain points in the season. That’s the kind of detail I’d bring up once I knew what someone was looking for.
In a 2025 study across five European countries, wine drinkers said they’d pay more for wine grown with lower pesticide use. The sales figures I found varied considerably by market. In 2024, organic wine accounted for an estimated 7% of French wine consumption by volume and about a quarter of the wine volume sold through Sweden’s Systembolaget. A shopper asking about a Napa Cab might be worried about residues or want to know more about the farm. Those sales figures leave their reasons open.
Consumer choice study · Agence BIO market report
When to spray and what to use
Cornell’s PhytoPatholoBot drives through vineyard rows, photographs the vines and uses computer vision to flag disease. In tests in research and commercial vineyards, it performed comparably to experienced scouts on the tasks researchers evaluated. Cornell also has an instrument called HyperBird that can pick up signs of infection in leaf samples before symptoms are visible.
PhytoPatholoBot field study · Cornell’s HyperBird research
In 2026, Bonterra sent six UV-C robots into about 200 acres of Chardonnay in Mendocino. The crew sprayed early while waiting for them to arrive, then used light through véraison, when the fruit begins to ripen. Bonterra’s farming director said the light controlled powdery mildew as well as or better than oil and sulfur in the comparison blocks. Over four years of independent trials in Oregon, control of powdery mildew on the fruit varied and bunch rot caused by Botrytis showed no significant reduction.
California Farm Bureau field reporting · Oregon UV-C trials
Silver Oak already sprayed at night, so its schedule stayed the same when it tested UV-C. What changed was the job. At each of two trial sites, a supervisor learned to use an iPad to oversee a pair of robots in rows that had previously been treated with a spray rig.
In Australia, growers can now use something from a sugar beet to help with Botrytis. The country registered the beet extract in 2026 as part of a broader disease program. It gets the vine’s own defenses going before infection. In five years of trial data from the Finger Lakes, Cornell found that some programs alternating biological and conventional fungicides could control both mildews as well as programs that used conventional products all season. In one 2025 trial, downy mildew got heavy earlier when researchers used biological products alone. I can see why a grower would keep a conventional fungicide available and use the other products when the crop can get by with them.
Australian Wine Research Institute on sugar beet extract · Cornell’s integrated management findings · Cornell’s 2025 field trial notes
The decision you make before planting
A grower putting in a new vineyard can make a decision about mildew before there’s anything to spray. In southern Sweden, longer growing seasons have helped growers ripen wine grapes. Solaris, an early-ripening grape that tolerates both mildews, has become a big part of the local industry. Even there, a wet site can give growers plenty to do about downy mildew.
Climate and wine production review · Swedish Solaris research · Decanter on Scandinavian vineyards
Over eight years, France’s OSCAR project tracked what happened in commercial vineyards planted with resistant grapes. Their fungicide treatment index, which accounts for dose and frequency, averaged 79% below the French benchmark for susceptible varieties. Some of the resistance to downy mildew weakened over time, and the researchers found black rot more often.
INRAE’s eight-year OSCAR findings
Who carries the grapes
I kept looking at what else was going down the rows. In a 2026 field trial on 16 vines, a prototype that uses cameras to guide its pruning cuts reached up to 82% task success. Another team used ground-level radar and a neural network to estimate the weight of the grapes before harvest, including bunches hidden by leaves. A grower could use an estimate like that to plan for people and trucks.
Vision-guided pruning study · Radar and neural-network yield study
At Terras Gauda in Galicia, four winery employees picked grapes by hand for two hours. Robots followed two of them down the rows and carried the boxes they filled. A full box averaged about 55 pounds. The workers with robots said they felt less tired and filled a box about six minutes faster on average. The researchers also used the results to model a harvest with a smaller crew. The winery would have to decide what to do with the time the robots saved.
Terras Gauda field study, sections 4.1–4.2 and 4.5
What goes into a bottle
I get the sense that more people are thinking about where their money goes and what they put into their bodies. After years of being sold on convenience and having more of everything, some of us want to know a little more about how the things we buy were made. I hear some of that in the way people talk about organic wine. One person might care most about what was sprayed on the grapes. Someone else might care as much about what it took for a crew to get those grapes out of the vineyard.
Then there’s the machinery. At Terras Gauda, a robot took a heavy box off a picker’s hands. The researchers also used the trial to estimate how the harvest could be done with fewer people. I keep thinking about what those two possibilities would mean to someone who depends on that work. With AI, I’d also want to know how much energy a particular system uses and what the vineyard gets out of running it. And some people may hear that AI was used to grow the grapes and decide to buy something else.
I sell wine, and I came to this because a story about grapes in Brazil made me wonder how people used to keep them from rotting. I can see why a grower would still pull leaves the way Columella described, or reach for sulfur, and be curious about what a camera could tell them about the same vines. The more I read, the more I find myself thinking about what any of those choices looks like to the person doing the work and what someone buying the wine would make of it if they knew.
Leave a Reply