When I first started working in the store, I drank a lot of cheap, big California reds. They were accessible, I liked plenty of them, and ten bucks was about what I wanted to spend.
My first regular liked those, too.
Then one day I decided to splurge. Thirty dollars instead of ten. I bought a 2015 Georges Descombes Morgon, and the first time I put my nose in the glass, the temporary wine-store job became permanent.
That bottle blew my mind. Changed my life, honestly.
A week or so later, my regular came in with the same idea: he wanted to spend a little more money. I gave him that bottle.
The next morning, the second we opened, he came running into the store looking for me, saying he was going to kiss me. Unfortunately, I wasn’t there, so I missed out on the kiss. He bought multiple bottles, including one for me that I finally drank in 2025.
I was very new to the industry. I didn’t have some deep knowledge of Beaujolais to share. I’d found something I loved, told him about it, and he trusted me enough to try it.
Almost ten years later, he still comes in asking what I’ve been drinking.
I have another regular I’ve served for roughly the same amount of time. He’s probably in his 70s now. For years, he bought two cases of white zinfandel every week. Same wine, no variation. Holidays didn’t change the order.
Eventually, he was buying one case a week. Now it might be a case a month. His visits have become infrequent enough that I’ve lost track.
I don’t know his reason. I can see how much his purchasing has changed.
Those two customers kept coming to mind while I was reading the latest wine sales reports.
Over the four weeks ending October 24, 2026, U.S. wine dollar sales fell 3.8% and volume fell 5.3% compared with the same period last year. Those NielsenIQ figures cover its measured retail channels and exclude wine-based cocktails.
In a separate October report, SipSource analysts identified wines below $13 as the biggest drag on the category, while wines at $16 and above were holding up comparatively better. SipSource tracks wholesaler deliveries to stores, restaurants and other accounts, so these are different measurements covering different periods.
The inexpensive end struggling most was the part that caught my attention.
In my experience, many older regulars head straight for the same large bottles and boxes they’ve bought for years. They know the product and the price. They rarely want help choosing. Those purchases have been dependable business.
I’ve also watched some of those customers come in less often or disappear altogether. Some regulars have cut back for health reasons. Retirement might change the budget. And eventually, a group of aging customers gets smaller.
You notice when purchases you could practically set your watch by stop happening.
Wine Market Council’s 2025 consumer survey identified Boomers as the generation with the greatest erosion in wine participation. Their share of U.S. wine drinkers fell from 32% in 2023 to 26% in 2025. Millennials became the largest group at 31%. These are shares of people who drink wine; they don’t tell us how much each generation buys or spends.
WMC gets more specific in its February 2026 analysis of under-$10 wine. It identifies older, frequent buyers who stick to familiar brands or wine types reducing consumption or aging out as one source of weakness. The analysis includes 1.5-liter and jug wines. It also says younger customers aren’t necessarily entering wine through that low-price segment.
That sounds a lot like what I’ve been seeing.
Generally, my older customers are more likely to ask, “Where is this?” Younger customers more often ask, “What is this?” Where’s it from? How’s it made? What would I buy?
Some of that could be experience. At 55 or 65, you’ve had plenty of time to find your favorites. I can’t tell you how much is life stage and how much is a generational difference. I’m describing a pattern I see in my store.
The younger customers also seem pretty comfortable with the idea that what the people working in the store actually drink might be worth trying. I’ve had far more Millennials and Gen Z customers ask what I like or what I’ve opened lately, then buy based on that conversation.
And the questions continue at the boxed-wine shelf. Someone can have a tight budget and still want to know which box I’d buy, what it tastes like and why I like it. They’re trying to get the best thing they can afford.
That’s where I think there’s an opportunity.
IWSR’s U.S. analysis, published in March 2024 using its 2023 data release, found that 73% of Millennial regular wine drinkers enjoyed trying new or different wine styles regularly. Among regular wine drinkers overall, it was 58%. It also found that 57% of Millennial regular wine drinkers drank wine on two or more days a week, compared with 46% overall.
There are interested customers here, including people who buy frequently. According to the same analysis, their engagement still hadn’t offset the category’s decline.
That’s the difficult part. Finding someone who wants to explore wine doesn’t necessarily replace the volume bought by someone who used to take home cases of it every week.
There’s also a limit to what anyone selling wine can fix. WMC’s February presentation reports that 53% of respondents reducing wine consumption in its 2025 benchmark survey attributed that reduction to cutting back on alcohol generally.
If somebody wants to drink less, a better sales pitch won’t change that. But when somebody is standing in the store wanting to buy wine, asking questions and looking for help, we have something to work with.
The pressure elsewhere in the industry is hard to ignore, too.
Global bulk-wine exports fell 14.5% in volume and 12.5% in value in the first half of 2026 compared with the first half of 2025, according to Del Rey AWM’s September presentation to the EU Wine Market Observatory. Its analysis identifies harvest conditions, prices and weakening demand as contributing factors. Bulk is a trading format covering different products and price points, so it doesn’t translate directly into the inexpensive wine on an American shelf.
Treasury Wine Estates outlined a five-year plan in June to reduce its portfolio from 76 brands to fewer than 30. The options for other brands include reducing production and sales, keeping them in selected markets, selling them or retiring them. Its plans also include disposing of surplus vineyards and wineries.
In Gironde, France, completed vineyard-removal programs covered approximately 12,300 hectares, according to the government’s January 2026 update. Some land was allocated to other uses and some to renaturation.
Each of those developments has its own circumstances. Together, they’re the kind of thing I look at and squint.
I think too much of the industry got comfortable. Cheap, high-volume wine seemed like safe business. Buy more brands, get bigger, keep making money. I think companies underestimated changing health priorities, interest in low- and no-alcohol drinks, and younger customers’ interest in supporting smaller businesses.
I also have a hard time believing the biggest companies are going to quietly accept getting smaller.
My guess is they’ll consolidate, cut costs and replace people with technology wherever they can. I see stories about technology advancing in wineries all the time. I expect companies to use it to protect their margins and stay big.
That’s a prediction. It’s also why I’m cautious about assuming corporate trouble automatically means smaller producers are about to have a great time.
Frenchtown Farms in North Yuba is a good example of what I like supporting. Aaron and Cara Mockrish are a husband-and-wife team who learned from Gideon Beinstock of Clos Saron. They’re hardworking, adventurous and dedicated, and they make great wines.
The production choices matter, and so do the people involved. I like feeling that my money is going to people whose work I respect. It doesn’t have to be a two-person winery, but I tend to lean away from the Joshes, KJs and Gallos of the world.
Good wine is good wine, though.
I roll my eyes at both sides of the Gallo argument. Defending everything a giant company does as if your life depends on it? Barf. Hating every wine it touches just because of the name? Also dumb.
As extreme as some of my beliefs are, I still find extremism so boring. I want to know what’s in the bottle and who’s behind it. There should be room to have an opinion after that.
What I find promising is hearing more industry people, especially Millennials, push for greater attention to smaller producers. I think that can help wine. If large companies become even more consolidated and automated, I hope the people behind smaller operations become more valuable to customers.
It may be harder for as many of those businesses to survive. And hoping people will support them because they understand what’s at stake is still hoping. People disappoint me almost as often as corporations do, so who knows.
The part I can actually do something about happens in the store.
I listen to what someone likes, what they need the wine for and what they can spend. Then I try to find something that fits and is good value. When that works, they have a reason to trust me next time.
That’s how discovery becomes repeat business. In my experience, younger customers are more willing to dance that dance.
I’m totally fine seeing large corporations lose some of their grip on the business. The job losses are harder to reckon with. Regular people work in those wineries, warehouses and distribution businesses. Their livelihoods can get caught up in decisions they had little control over.
I don’t have an easy answer for that.
The older guy who only drinks Caymus or Vella may have helped me with the down payment. I’ll need new customers to finish paying the mortgage.
I’d like to think there’s a future in helping them find something they love.
It worked with my first regular. I was new, drinking ten-dollar reds and learning alongside him. Almost ten years later, he’s still asking what I’ve been drinking.
Leave a Reply